It's a delicate situation when your child has trouble with a teacher. You really have to treat the situation very carefully, because your child has to continue dealing with the teacher on a daily basis, at least for the rest of the school year. And it's even worse if the child has younger siblings, because causing any kind of trouble at all might result in problems in the future. "Oh, he's THAT guy's kid?!?" No, not something I want said about either of my children--at least, not in THAT way.
My oldest is a sixth grader. His school has three sixth grade classes. Each of the three teachers teaches a couple of subjects. The classes rotate between the classrooms. This will hopefully be a preparation for Junior High next year.
Lately, my sixth grader has had problems in math. Part of their week includes something called "Mountain Math." Each week, the math teacher puts up a bulletin board that is part of a kit that he has purchased. The Mountain Math bulletin board looks like this:

The student is given a sheet with questions on it. Questions like these:
11. Estimate the sum. ___________ Write the actual sum. _________
12. Find the Perimeter. ________________
In this particular math class, the teacher has them do Mountain Math as a "self-starter" activity, and during times when the student has finished other work or has nothing else to do, they are supposed to work on Mountain Math. Their answer sheet has to be completed by the end of the week, and at the end of the week, the sheet is graded.
This math teacher has added a dimension to Mountain Math. Each week, he sets a number of problems that is the maximum that a student should miss. If a student misses more than this number, then they have to join the "tutoring club" for the following week.
Tutoring club basically means that the student must eat his lunch in the classroom and use the recess time to work on Mountain Math. In the past, the teacher would also eat his lunch in the classroom and would be there to help the kids learn. But for the last several weeks, the math teacher disappears and the kids are left, unsupervised, to fend for themselves. No tutoring is going on (so why not call it punishment, because that's what it is), and very little math gets done at all.
Now, understand that all of this information is second-hand to me. I hear it from the point of view of a rather imaginitive 11-year-old. In order to better understand the situation, I went to have lunch with my son a couple of weeks ago, and the situation was pretty much as he described it to me.
Yesterday, I wrote the following email to the math teacher:
Mr. XXXXXXXX
My son, XXXXX, is in the "tutoring club" once again and has expressed some frustration with it. I'm wondering if there is anything I can do to help out. Since Mountain Math is put up on a bulletin board at school, I never see the problems. I never see the answers. I never see what gaps there are in his understanding of the math concepts so that I can help him learn and understand what he is missing. [My son] also tends to work more slowly than others and has sometimes voiced concern that he can complete the problems in the time provided, but often doesn't have the time to double check his work. Is there an accompanying sheet that goes along with Mountain Math that [my son] can bring home so that I can help? If there is no printed resource available, will you allow [my son] to take a digital photograph of the Mountain Math bulletin board so that he can work on it with less stress?
I'm also a bit concerned about the "tutoring club." [My son] described to me what it used to be versus what it has become. He said that earlier in the year, you would eat your lunch in the classroom and be there as a resource to help them with Mountain Math when they needed it. He said that currently, tutoring club seems more like a punishment for doing poorly than a resource to help them do better because you no longer spend any of this tutoring club time in the classroom, tutoring. I thought he must be exaggerating, but a couple of weeks ago, I came and ate lunch with [my son], and it was pretty chaotic. Very little, if any, math got done at all, and there was certainly no supervision and no tutoring happening. Please help me better understand the purpose of the tutoring club, because what I see is from the point of view of an 11-year-old who has little hope that he will be able to spend another lunch recess outdoors and have a break from the classroom. This has become not a learning experience for him, but rather is a point of frustration and perceived failure. Having done very well in math myself in school, and having enjoyed the subject, I naturally want my son to have a more positive experience than he seems to be having.
Thank you,
Apparently, my son (and this email) was the topic of conversation among the sixth grade teachers suring their lunch today. They were comparing notes on how well my son uses his classroom time. How do I know this? Well, I have a very good friend that also happens to be a teacher at the school and this friend sat near the sixth grade teachers during lunch today and listened in.
I know that he's a rather imaginative sort. He doesn't use all of his time in class wisely. He's often doodling on his paper or talking to someone else. This is something that we're aware of and trying to help him work on. I understand completely why this might have been the topic of conversation. But why was that teacher in the teacher's lounge discussing my son rather than being in the classroom supervising my son?
I won't reprint the teacher's reply, because I don't have his permission. He agreed that the situation is exactly as I described, but he said that the events that led up to the current situation are too lengthy to put in an email. So I'm meeting with this teacher on Thursday morning to discuss this further.
I'm frankly a bit pissed off about the whole situation.
If my son uses his class time that poorly, why am I just finding out now, about four weeks before the end of the school year? What is the point of a "tutoring club" when there is no tutoring going on AT ALL? Why are the kids in the "tutoring club" left completely unsupervised during this time? If the teacher requires them to be there, I think the teacher should be required to supervise during this time. How can I find out what math skills my son is doing poorly on if I have no access to the questions/answers. I can see my son's answer sheet, but it makes no sense whatsoever without the accompanying bulletin board display.
But the worst of it is this: How can I actually do anything without worrying about what problems this may cause for my son during the rest of this school year and for my other son three years down the road? As evidenced by Mr. Math Teacher's reaction to a simple (and non-attacking, might I add) email, I have to tiptoe carefully around the situation, making sure that nothing I say or do offends this teacher. I have to tapdance around the issue, for fear that I might upset the teacher and risk my children being treated poorly. And heaven forbid that I go over his head, because that would give offense as well. As my friend put it:
Lack of supervision is an issue you could bring up with Mr. [Principal's name]. Just be aware the teachers might not like that.
In other words, I'm completely powerless in the situation and I'd better get used to it.